Re: Part 9 - This is the chair (SPOILERS)
Posted: Sun Jul 09, 2017 10:00 pm
madeleineferguson wrote:
a Twin Peaks and David Lynch Electrical Resource
https://dugpa.com/forum/
madeleineferguson wrote:
This is fair. From a conventional television narrative storytelling standpoint, it's insane that this plot has been totally ignored for three straight hours. But when viewed as an 18-hour movie, we have to accept that TP:TR is stretching time and storytelling to the breaking point.LateReg wrote:While It's true that Andy's presence in Part 9 made me wonder why we didn't see him talking about his investigation into the hit and run vehicle, it hasn't really been "weeks," of course. It's just been a day since he talked to that guy who failed to meet up with him. I'm wondering if he already told Truman about it offscreen, and if the investigation is under control and we'll hear about its progress next week (it could still be the same day as this Part), or in typical Andy fashion if he hasn't gotten a chance to tell anyone about it yet. It's a little odd, but if we were watching it as a continuous movie in which it's easier to grasp the timeline and didn't have to wait weeks in between episodes, I don't think it would feel all that odd. Plot points are generally revisited in the proper, natural time frame, in my opinion.Mr. Reindeer wrote:(Somewhat related note: No one has mentioned the kid Richard ran over in several weeks. I generally don't mind this show being all over the place, but within the world of the TP sherff's station, you'd think Truman would be more concerned with solving the killing of a local kid as opposed to following up tangents from a 25-year-old closed case.)
I've wondered if this could be the result as well but I would not be a fan... No FBI? Fine I guess but I'd at least like him to return to Twin Peaks. All though 2/3 people most important to him there are gone..FlyingSquirrel wrote:Somebody mentioned the possibility, and I wonder if there's something to it, that Cooper might decide to continue being "Dougie" if and when he regains full control of his faculties. Not that I think he'd pretend not to have remembered who he is, but rather that he might - once he's done whatever he can to thwart DoppelCooper and any other Black Lodge types - decide not to return to the FBI or stay in Twin Peaks. Not only is he likely to feel a lot of guilt and trauma over everything that's happened, but I wonder if he'd also feel like he owes something to Janey-E and Jim, and he might have hoped to have a family some day back before the events of the original series turned his life completely upside-down.Jonah wrote:Forgot to add - I really like how it's developing the Bobby/Garland connection. Very moving.
I hope we see Audrey soon. And Laura again.
Is the hum Josie or not? Hmmmm.
Not much else to add. A good episode, a little slow, but moving things forward and connecting back.
Who else thinks Janey-E is going to go to Twin Peaks with Dougie/Cooper?
Didn't DoppelCooper losing it in the car and the swap between the real Cooper and Dougie happen at 2:53 p.m. too?master468 wrote:madeleineferguson wrote:
I think he'll go back to the town. I just mean that he might not end up staying there once he's done whatever he needs to do. In the original series he was seemingly thinking about buying property there because he'd become so fond of the place. Now, it might just be too many unpleasant reminders.WhiteLodge90 wrote:I've wondered if this could be the result as well but I would not be a fan... No FBI? Fine I guess but I'd at least like him to return to Twin Peaks. All though 2/3 people most important to him there are gone..FlyingSquirrel wrote:Somebody mentioned the possibility, and I wonder if there's something to it, that Cooper might decide to continue being "Dougie" if and when he regains full control of his faculties. Not that I think he'd pretend not to have remembered who he is, but rather that he might - once he's done whatever he can to thwart DoppelCooper and any other Black Lodge types - decide not to return to the FBI or stay in Twin Peaks. Not only is he likely to feel a lot of guilt and trauma over everything that's happened, but I wonder if he'd also feel like he owes something to Janey-E and Jim, and he might have hoped to have a family some day back before the events of the original series turned his life completely upside-down.Jonah wrote:Forgot to add - I really like how it's developing the Bobby/Garland connection. Very moving.
I hope we see Audrey soon. And Laura again.
Is the hum Josie or not? Hmmmm.
Not much else to add. A good episode, a little slow, but moving things forward and connecting back.
Who else thinks Janey-E is going to go to Twin Peaks with Dougie/Cooper?
Was just about to point that out, figured that had already been revealed but now we see the time again...FlyingSquirrel wrote:Didn't DoppelCooper losing it in the car and the swap between the real Cooper and Dougie happen at 2:53 p.m. too?master468 wrote:madeleineferguson wrote:
this is perfectfearless leader wrote:bEST Line of Part 9: "I am not your foot".
I hope somehow Jerry is the one that ties it all together.