I think Cooper is BACK. Really, really back. He doesn't just look like our Agent Cooper --- there's a look of recognition and confidence in his face that we haven't seen before. Well we didn't see him after the electrocution. And up to that point, even though he seemed to exhibit a strong sense of ...

430RichardandLinda wrote:WHAT AN EPISODE. WOW. SO DID COOPER FINALLY WAKE HIMSELF UP WITH ELECTROCUTION????
.

Either that or he is dead (which I don't expect him to be). I don't see how that electrocution wouldn't have a profound impact, so it's gotta be one or the other.

I don't remember more than maybe one or two posts on the board saying, "Hmmmmm, maybe this isn't such a good idea." That view WAS expressed before The Return was announced, when a third season of TP was a hypothetical. But after the announcement EVERYBODY was positive. We were absolutely ...

Well said, depechehenke. Let me just quote mlsstwrt, in the very fines lines of the very first post, detailing the purpose of this thread: The title says it all. There's a lot of heated and interesting debate/discussion going on in the main Season 3 threads. This thread isn't meant for that. It is, ...

love this thread tbh :lol: haters mad at lovers lovers amused by haters What a fair and nuanced characterization. If you have legitimate criticism you must be a "HATER". Your purpose is to HATE. You realize your comment comes across ironically both as hateful and needlessly condescending?...

I think it's also bizarre that detractors of THE RETURN are criticized for being nostalgic for favoring the original series. While the diehard supporters of THE RETURN keep saying that Lynch is returning to the styles and motifs of ERASERHEAD and his short films, which they love!!! How's that not b...

I loved how Ray was super confident that Doppel Coop would get his ass handed to him in arm wrestling. This after having witnessed Doppel Coop having mind blowing supernatural elements on his side. After having seen him cheat death in the most insane, supernatural fashion. And yet he is willing to ...

I loved how Ray was super confident that Doppel Coop would get his ass handed to him in arm wrestling. This after having witnessed Doppel Coop having mind blowing supernatural elements on his side. After having seen him cheat death in the most insane, supernatural fashion. And yet he is willing to r...

Was anyone else waiting for that suit of clothes in the shadows in Sara's living room to start walking? I was watching the mirrors. When the scene had gone on for far too long, I thought "Yet another one of these slow scenes where nothing happens, we get it, it's a painfully sad existence for ...

It seemed to me that Agent327 was implying as much as part of his/her argument, but I don't want to put words in anyone's mouth. That's what I was replying to, tho'. If it seemed that way to you, I think you missed what I actually wrote, and what I quoted/replied to. Of course it's possible to have...

I disagree with your premise for one simple reason: I do love and enjoy this season. "Viewer enjoyment" is ok; apparently there are many like me. It's just very subjective. Of course it's subjective. The music of Beethoven or Mozart is not objectively better than someone recording a fart....

Instead it all feels a bit mundane and colorless. There is a complex story in there, I'm sure, but it doesn't translate itself into overall enjoyable viewing. I think in order to defend the new season you really have to make the argument that 'viewer enjoyment' is part of 'poor man's criticism'. As...

Things like sweeping the floor, staring at each other, Candie (need I say anything?) is what ultimately led me here. I am a patient man, I really man. Hell, I have watched 12 episodes before coming to this thread. Many of the actors showed massive support to Lynch when Showtime was negotiating with...

Yeah Gabriel you turncoat ;-) Just kidding, very nice to see you post here. The Audrey scene was terrible. I don't think she posts in here but I wonder what Audrey Horne (the Dugpa poster) made of it? I adored Audrey in the Original but she seems to be awful now. I'm finding it deeply depressing at...

It was great! . No. It just flat out wasn't. I can understand people who manage to get through the episode, and like things like Gordon's lady friend scene. I thought that was fine. But If this is deemed to be "great" by anyone it shows a confirmation bias that is beyond insanity. The ori...