Season 4? Or is it over after this?

[Jerry Horne]

Since we're going down the rabbit hole...let's not forget that Lynch has already concieved a special feature (Between Two Worlds) that has actors in character. Maybe they filmed something new like that and wanted that location.

[Jonah]

A DVD feature or maybe a series of webisodes for Showtime. There's pretty much no way they could be filming a movie or a new season (even just started pre-production) without word leaking, is there?

[Rainwater]

I thought none of the interiors were filmed in the Salish?

[bob_wooler]

Do we actually know something happened then? Or is it just based on their Twin Peaks vibe tweet?

All we have is a confluence of events that include the Dining Room shutting down for a day or two.

This room?

[Jerry Horne]

Yes. Behind the camera is the view.

[Jonah]

Saw some photos on Google where you can see the Falls from the window.

The more I think about it, it probably just is another "Between Two Worlds"-like feature. I could see Lynch sitting there, interviewing some of the cast. But I hope it's more.

[sneakydave]

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I've always wanted to see my face on dugpa....

[JohnGSmoke]

Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

I've always wanted to see my face on dugpa....

lol


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk

[tylergfoster]

To go back to the Daily Beast interview with Kyle MacLachlan for a moment, somewhere around the middle, the author mentions that the interview took place at TCA 2019, which places it a month earlier than the rumors, and a month before the article went online.

[Jasper]

To go back to the Daily Beast interview with Kyle MacLachlan for a moment, somewhere around the middle, the author mentions that the interview took place at TCA 2019, which places it a month earlier than the rumors, and a month before the article went online.

Thanks for pointing that out. I'd wondered when the interview took place, but I'd yet to read the entire thing. It was curious that the question wasn't asked in the context of the widespread rumors. If the interview had taken place more recently, instead of admitting to the routine nature of such a question, the author might have framed it as being timely in light of the recent hype.

[pinballmars]

If David Lynch scratches his right ear in the middle of answering a question about the future of Twin Peaks, SOMEONE will interpret that as something meaningful. ("Notice that he scratched his RIGHT ear! That means that he's saying that the question is on the RIGHT track! Also, watch the way that he pauses in the middle of of it. Clearly, that means that the Season 4 script is already written!")

Twin Peaks fans right now are like a guy anazlying every word and syllable in a girl's voicemail message trying to determine if she likes you. They're given VERY little to work with, but they're determined to read so much into every nanosecond of information.

Y'all blow up EVERYTHING. Even if it's a tweet from a source that 99% of us hadn't even heard of before.

That's why I am skeptical x 100 about the new rumors.

THAT SAID, would I love to hear about new Twin Peaks? FUCK YES. I would love to be wrong.

But, gotta say, that so far I'm not really feeling it...

[PandemoniumSeesaw]

Just a thought I am writing here so that you guys can debunk it, as I don't like having false hopes. Is it possible that when Lynch bailed out of the project and then came back with Nevins saying "the cup is even bigger than we expected" they actually agreed on two seasons and directly produced and directed both of them and are just waiting for the right moment to postproduce/publish the second part? Just a list of reasons this sounds plausible:

• The removal of "Complete" from the television series box set
• Showtime listing The Return as The Return - Season 1
• I haven't heard of any "missing pieces" of The Return which sounds strange as I don't think it is usual directing 18 hours of material without some "leftover" scenes

I don't really believe what I have just hypothesised, I am just hoping for you to give me good reasons why this is not possible at all.

[Jonah]

There was a theory called "Season 3B" I think making the rounds on reddit which is very reminiscent of what you're talking about. While possible, it's extremely unlikely. Sabrina Sutherland indicated most of the footage shot was used. Even by watching The Return itself, you get the feeling not much was held back and most of the footage shot (the sweeping scene, etc.) wasn't cut down much. I could at most envision perhaps a couple of hours of content (ala The Missing Pieces) being left over, but even then I think it's unlikely. But definitely not a whole season's worth of content. The behind the scenes footage shows examples of Lynch complaining about the tight schedule, lack of time, etc. There's no way they shot a whole parallel season while shooting The Return. I mean, it is possible, just extremely unlikely imo. The things you mentioned could be indicative of Showtime planning for/hoping for another Season in the future, though. And some footage could have been shoot - a few scenes, some on location stuff, for that or an upcoming movie. But I highly doubt there's much more than that.

[BGate]

Just a thought I am writing here so that you guys can debunk it, as I don't like having false hopes. Is it possible that when Lynch bailed out of the project and then came back with Nevins saying "the cup is even bigger than we expected" they actually agreed on two seasons and directly produced and directed both of them and are just waiting for the right moment to postproduce/publish the second part? Just a list of reasons this sounds plausible:

• The removal of "Complete" from the television series box set
• Showtime listing The Return as The Return - Season 1
• I haven't heard of any "missing pieces" of The Return which sounds strange as I don't think it is usual directing 18 hours of material without some "leftover" scenes

I don't really believe what I have just hypothesised, I am just hoping for you to give me good reasons why this is not possible at all.

Because it isn't, for about a million reasons. But the most obvious one is this: in this hypothetical 2nd season, they used literally all the same cast and locations? That sounds kinda boring to me...



The reason there are no deleted scenes is because Lynch had carte blanche to make literally whatever he wanted, and make it as long as he wanted, as long as he stayed within budget. I assure you if his other movies were produced under these circumstances they would have a lot fewer deleted scenes as well.

[PandemoniumSeesaw]

The reason there are no deleted scenes is because Lynch had carte blanche to make literally whatever he wanted, and make it as long as he wanted, as long as he stayed within budget. I assure you if his other movies were produced under these circumstances they would have a lot fewer deleted scenes as well.

Well, on this, I don't agree. INLAND EMPIRE was produced with A LOT of creative freedom and still it has 1h15 worth of extra material.