Exactly what I was thinking. Also the urge for additional material like "scripts and BTS footage" and this insatiable hunger for another Season feels ungrateful about all what has been created already. Since when is shouting "encore!" an ungrateful thing? I don't understand that...

meadowlark wrote: Also, Mrs Temond and her grandson Pierre were great characters. Could they be re-cast?

They were

Yes, and I think that's why they didn't do anything with Chet. The Jeffries and Desmond storyline possibilities might've been too similar. Once Bowie wasn't able to do it, it might have been too late to switch the two.

Frost said in his Reddit ama that they couldn't think of any storyline for Desmond Specifically, what Frost wrote was: "Chet was discussed but we found no easy way to bring him back from wherever he is." https://www.reddit.com/r/twinpeaks/comments/7bn45h/im_mark_frost_cocreator_of_twin_pe...

N. Needleman wrote:

Jasper wrote:
I'd be shocked if anything new was announced so soon

I am shocked that it has taken this long (regardless of it was a "working on it" or "that's it forever" announcement).

I thought I remembered reading that the spike didn’t last after the show ended, but I think I’m misremembering (or remembering speculation rather than actual facts). In any event, I still hold to my contention that the show was by most coventional analyses at best a very modest success, and I’m per...

I don't see how it's debatable since the writers have told us that this was their intention. It is also the thematic basis for everything that happens in the rest of episode 17 and 18. Frost absolutely said Freddie was them experimenting with deus ex machina, yes. He never said it was purely satiri...

N. Needleman wrote:I don't think any of it was ever written for Donna.

Don't think so either. Season 2 left us with Donna departing the town. It would take more than a little re-writing swapping Gersten's plot for Donna. Besides I think Lynch is a fan of Witt's acting. She is really great in "Hotel Room":

N. Needleman wrote:

eyeboogers wrote: This is debatable. To me it's yes and no.

I don't see how it's debatable since the writers have told us that this was their intention. It is also the thematic basis for everything that happens in the rest of episode 17 and 18.

krishnanspace wrote:Also the early draft had Naido play a completely different role and there was hardly any Twin Peaks

Source? especially for the Naido part?

Comments from Lynch recently have made it clear that the Palmer house ending of s3 is very much not the 'golden age' but a sad ending. Could you expand upon the above? What would have been a golden age, and what did Lynch say that makes it a sad ending? You'll find that section in this interview: h...

No idea why I just thought of it, but my goodness that Green Glove thing was just plain inept. I think that is one case where it is actually fair to say "you just don't get it". How ironic it is that it's you who just don't get it. Lynch and Frost failed to deliver a satisfying arc for BO...

No idea why I just thought of it, but my goodness that Green Glove thing was just plain inept. I think that is one case where it is actually fair to say "you just don't get it". The show is making a point about how there are no easy solutions or quick fixes in life. You have to dig yourse...

krishnanspace wrote:Damon Lindelof being a huge Twin Peaks fan could be able to understand Lynch and Frost's vision and the audiences expectations

Lindeloff should make his own (great) shows, and Lynch/Frost should make theirs. Why would you want a cover band?

In one of his recent interviews, he said that when he began shooting season 3 he was active and that now he can barely walk. I'm definitely going to need a source for this one. He did say that, but it was in jest (about being exhausted after the months of work) it wasn't meant to be taken literally.