He literally just said it was dull. That was the extent of his detailed analysis. Lol. Jonah, I know you said much more than that, and so do many other people. Don't sweat it. ;) In fairness, Jonah didn't claim to be providing a detailed analysis, I was responding to your assessment of his post. I ...

fluorescent light wrote:but y'all are like Charlie Brown trying to kick Lucy's football if you think Lynch is ever going to provide resolution

This is actually a really apt analogy for how part 18 functioned.

crash_and_burn wrote:

Jonah wrote:
Oh well.

Thank you for taking the time to spell out in more detail why Part 18 was so disappointing.

For the record, I absolutely loved Part 17.

I'm headed to the bar.

Fuck this shit ending.

He literally just said it was dull. That was the extent of his detailed analysis.

I'm speechless and it's going to take me a while to unpack that. Gotta hand it to Lynch, he intentionally leaked the end of the whole thing and still made it completely unexpected and confounding. It wasn't intentional but yeah, you can't spoil something that is literally indecipherable to begin wi...

Didn't see this posted: Interview with Sherilyn . Seems like she hasn't watched much of the show. I respect that her priorities are with her kids, but that's rather disappointing. She also clearly hates Showtime, and even admits to having some issues with Lynch at one point, which I think we all so...

IMO, *bad* FX is when someone tries to make something look "real" and fails. In re: TPTR, look no further than Mr. Todd's head shot. If there's *one* thing Hollywood FX pros know how to do, it's gunshots. Instead, we got that. It's clear that Lynch is making an artistic decision that cert...

I hate to be harsh, but what? She did not say that, it does not mean that, and man, it was NOT "bad Cgi" it was exactly what Lynch wanted. Do you have a better video of what REALLY happens when a tulpa breaks down to seed? Its not meant to be realistic. Its art. It looks exactly like Lync...

Wait, who was Bellina Logan??

Naturally this was my favorite part so far. No mention yet... But no one thought when Audrey dances and someone smashed the glass, it's what set her off from the dream... She runs over to her guide/brain and says "get me out of here!" It seemed like her first real declarative sentence. Sh...

Guys I really think Audrey's in some kind of hypnotherapy. That's why she runs to Charlie (who's running it/her doctor) and says "Get me out of here"

So, Audrey *is* in some kind of hypno-therapy? Cooper asked Gerard to create another Tulpa (presumably of himself?)??

I totally predicted that Audrey and Charlie would get to the Roadhouse in time to see Vedder! I can prove it too! lol

Lynch did say "necessity is the mother of invention" with respect to the arm-tree, so I think they definitely planned on using MJA at some point. Maybe they caught wind of his issues before they finished the script. Sources say he dropped out the day before filming Ike's attack on Dougie,...

Lynch did say "necessity is the mother of invention" with respect to the arm-tree, so I think they definitely planned on using MJA at some point. Maybe they caught wind of his issues before they finished the script.

I'm loathe to do this, but I'm bored so

8
15
1-2
5
3
10
11
14
6
4
13
12
7
9