Where does this idea come from that a line Gordon Cole says has to represent something about Lynch as a filmmaker? He is playing a character in Season 3. What other lines in this are Lynch speaking to the audience through Cole? I can't remember others being cited. If there were other examples of thi...

Another Blue Rose and Mr Strawberry - you're making lengthy posts but I don't know your reasons for not liking season 3. Can you be more specific please? If you tell us that the total lack of Cooper throughout the season was a big problem for you that makes perfect sense to me. I also found that to ...

He’s been asked before if he thinks Lynch and Frost might do another season of “Twin Peaks,” and MacLachlan says his comments that it’s possible have been a bit overplayed. “I don’t think so,” MacLachlan says of the prospect of more “Twin Peaks.” “I kind of take the line of ‘never say never,’” he ad...

And yet you're still here ... You sound like a member of a gentlemen's private members club. Not at all. It's just that when someone continuously expresses such dislike-bordering-on-disgust with the thread in question (you've labelled it a "haven for misogynistic nastiness" just recently)...

No I wasn't saying it doesn't matter. Serious criticism of a tv show or film is important. The fact that this nasty whole 'Support Group' thread is nothing of the sort but now just a haven for misogynistic nastiness tells me all I need to know! And yet you're still here ... You sound like a member ...

No I wasn't saying it doesn't matter. Serious criticism of a tv show or film is important. The fact that this nasty whole 'Support Group' thread is nothing of the sort but now just a haven for misogynistic nastiness tells me all I need to know!

According to Audrey "sometime dreams hearken a truth" and inline with this I would like to add this paradox "the beginning of TPS3 was not the beginning of TPS3." I have this gut-feeling that understanding the "when, why and how" of Cooper meeting the Giant also would ...

If people are going to be wholly disrespectful or negative towards Twin Peaks they should be quite able to overcome any viewpoints that come along in response. Even if I really didn't like season 3, I wouldn't make an avatar saying 'the TURD season' as I have too much respect for Lynch, Frost and c...

They were not supposed to be a defeat of any kind to Gabriel, just a response. When there is such strong reaction to season 3 its bound to be responded to, right? Then why don't you use your own words if I may ask? Using those of others, mean comments from social media on top of that, maybe not the...

More responses: "To me, it kind of reads like a pompous writer trying to sound collegiate. People are more than entitled to dislike the show and have a negative opinion, but this specifically comes off pretentious and a bit shallow. Good vocabulary doesn't always indicate intelligent critical ...

Given TPTR is the epitome of postmodernism, anyone with any genuine intellect should dismiss it for the cultural irrelevance it is. It’s not art. It’s also possible to be objective about art (unless you’re a postmodernist, in which case any old crap can be called ‘art.’) My values come from the Enl...

Season 3 was written like this deliberately, so Lynch and Frost designed it to be this way. You could view it as a missed opportunity in some senses. I mean, if we had 18 episodes of Cooper back in full Special Agent detective mode, it would have been a very different season right? However, I do fe...

OK after a few months away from this thing I really like it again... Golly, I've never had such a love/hate relationship with a movie or show before like this! l: As far as the back and forth between liking and hating it, I also can't come up with anything comparable. I still haven't rewatched the ...

In reply to Boske, this season 'demolishes the legacy and spirit of what Twin Peaks was about?' That's a very grand judgement to make. I think you're wrong to say that as this season is very much about traumatic events and fear - which were always part of the show. Its one season and it doesn't mean...

Does it come down to Showtime wanting a few name actors? So we get Belushi, Knepper and Leigh in non-essential roles? That's a major complaint from me anyway. This is, of course, utterly false. Sorry I worded that badly. I meant to say that I would have preferred if those roles had gone to relative...