I love The Return, but I'm so hesitant about all this. I can't deny I would be open to, and excited for, a potential season 4. But I can't help thinking that a further continuation could leave all the really poignant themes of finality and loss in season 3 a little less potent. In my opinion the st...

Why do you think they'd move it to CBS All Access from Showtime? This is all speculation but my guess is the incremental viewership Twin Peaks would bring would have more of an impact on the All Access subscriber base than on Showtime's. A lot of Twin Peaks viewers were already subscribers to Showt...

Like most of you, I feel that the likelihood of a Season 4 will rest 99.9% on Lynch's and Frost's positions rather than on corporate/financial pressures. That being said, I could see Season 4 being a PERFECT fit for CBS's All Access Streaming Platform. I am sure the CBS executives are looking at the...

Good eye! That being said, the link is for a fan made transcript of ep.19 and not the actual script, so the table being formica might not have been important to Peyton/Engels. Would be interesting to see the actual script. I checked the actual script, and there's no mention of the table being formi...

On a related note, how awesome would it be if Lynch and Frost allowed the original draft to be published (along with annotations) as a pseudo-third volume of the Secret History/Final dossier series? I know the chances are incredibly slim, given Lynch's reluctance to comment on his works, but it woul...

Man From Another Place and Philip Gerard[/b]: It’s too bad about Michael J. Anderson. What a treat it would be to see the Episode 2 Red Room sequence come together again in Part 2 of the new season again. I would have loved to see how they would have handled the Red Room sequences with Anderson. Wo...

This is all just speculation, but Phillip Gerard's M.O. is different in S3. He's almost like Cooper's mystical Q (Bond Q, not Star Trek Q). That's not a complaint... just as amused observation. Very interesting. I also wonder what Gerard's role would have been in the new series had Michael J. Ander...

Based on what happened at the Sheriff's Station, it appears as though BOB could easily dispatch Dale Cooper, but the question remains as to whether or not a BOB-inhabited Mr. C could do the same. Good point, though it does illustrate one of the things I least liked about 'The Return.' I absolutely ...

Here's a question: Why on earth would Mr. C leave this to hired goons? Wouldn't he want to handle this with his own two hands? After all, that's the only way to ensure something is done to your satisfaction. My take is that the window to access the Fireman's realm was very tight, and it overlapped ...

Random question, and sorry, I haven't rewatched S3 in a while... I forget, how does Mr. C even know Coop was able to safely escape the Lodge to order the hit in Vegas? Couldn't he have just safely assumed Dougie the tulpa was sucked back in instead as he planned? As I understood it, Mr. C knew that...

[ Frost implies the world will end if Judy and Bob meet, so I don't think she's been harboring Sarah until recently, the frog has been dormant. Otherwise I don't see why the world didn't end much, much earlier if Judy and Bob were living together... Also it doesn't make sense that Dopplecoop needs ...

I am going with the thought that Sarah Palmer doesn't become fully possessed by Judy until it's released from the glass box, the Frog Bug is just something that was planted in her that marks her as a person that Judy can possess Ah, good point. Yeah, I could see that being the case. But this sort o...

The motive to mate with Judy to bring about the end of the world. But didn't that already kinda happen with Sarah/Joudy mating with Leland/BOB to produce Laura? Why would a union with the Double/BOB and Sarah/Joudy be any more calamitous than that? The only explanation I can think of is that the Do...

Just finished the book and, on a whole, I found it a lot more enjoyable than THE SECRET HISTORY. While I admire Frost's attempts in that first book at sticking to the epistolary format, I much prefer a more straightforward, chronological narrative, which is more in line with what we're getting in TF...

Am I the only one who is convinced Bobby or Shelly killed Leo? The cops didn't know that Windom Earle left Leo alive so there was no probable cause to charge them. Also Shelly had no way of knowing Leo wasn't evil anymore since he had tried to kill her last they met. I can't figure out how they loc...