Oh, one more reason I think we can assume the original timeline is fine: In 18, before Cooper and Diane cross over, Dougie II goes home to Janey-E and Sonny Jim, who clearly have been waiting on his return just as they were in 16. Without Laura's death and the subsequent investigation there is no p...

Dale creates a world where the mystery is not who killed Laura Palmer, but Where is Laura Palmer? Laura is still a member of that world, her missing is not going to change people's names. What you have is a world where I believe Ronetta is killed instead of Laura. Leland kills her and plants the B l...

Dale creates a world where the mystery is not who killed Laura Palmer, but Where is Laura Palmer? Laura is still a member of that world, her missing is not going to change people's names. What you have is a world where I believe Ronetta is killed instead of Laura. Leland kills her and plants the B l...

The two youtube shows that I have followed with the series have not updated. I think they threw in the towel along with most of the fans. It sorta sucks, because a few of them are really quite knowledgeable about the show and some of the number sequences. I think we have to realize this ending was a...

My questions about Judy: Judy is in fact the Experiment/Mother, correct? The figure Mr. C was searching for. And do we assume that Judy in now in Sarah? Was the thing that escaped the glass box Judy/Experiment/Mother? And if so, do we then assume that it only possessed Sarah AFTER that? Which we wo...

If people start hating on Dale after this then all of this is an abject failure.

So, I had to phone a friend to understand what happened, because my feed got jumbled. So, Lynch pulled a JJ Star Trek move. Our original timeline is safe. Bob is destroyed. Mr. C is returned to the lodge and Dale returns to save Diane. Dale even gets a moment with the people he loves. Then he jumps ...

N. Needleman wrote:I don't think Cooper can break the cycle. Not alone, anyway. I think it would have to be up to Laura, or others. Coop can be there but if there's one lesson from the end of both Season 2 and The Return it's that he is fundamentally flawed.

Well, he has Laura, so he can pull it off.

This!!!!! +1. I want a Season 4. Not because I want answers, but I want to see the Fireman guide Richard/Cooper thru this darkness to rediscover his kinder identity. There seemed to be a central theme to The Return that our Cooper radiated warmth and was healing the world around him (i.e. the Mitch...

This!!!!! +1. I want a Season 4. Not because I want answers, but I want to see the Fireman guide Richard/Cooper thru this darkness to rediscover his kinder identity. There seemed to be a central theme to The Return that our Cooper radiated warmth and was healing the world around him (i.e. the Mitch...

There won't be a season four. There is a story to tell but the way I see it, it's too raw to go back to anytime soon. Ironically it needs another 25 year gap lol. There wont be a season four because there is no financial foundation for it. Unless we all start crowd funding. That's the only way it c...

The whole its a dream thing maybe one of the most unsatisfying endings of all time. To me, the show ends with all of them in the police station and Dale kissing Diane. I also hate they broke their own rules about the Black Lodge. It just sucks Dale, Diane and Cole up instead of entering in a physica...

That sound you hear is a fandom tearing itself apart. Episode 17 was amazing stuff though. Everything I wanted. Could have left it there maybe saved Audrey, maybe she is in room 315 or you know something. Nope...we did that. An announcement for Season 4 had better come like nowish.

Any Takers?

We should do a poll or give odds on who will die in the finale. I am going with Norma and/or Ed, all the versions of Dale, Harry and possibly Mrs. Palmer.