I cannot see how anyone who loved the original show could reconcile the absolute incoherent mess that is Season three. There is some series disconnect... its a contradiction. You are either not getting how Season three ruins the original or you are not getting the nuance of the original. You simply...

Wow, I've been to work and come back and find 20 more pages on this thread and it's taken me an hour to read the posts! Was a bit shocked by some of the posts, no need to be nasty to one another. Just a note to those who love the show, please remember those who are disappointed and who are in 'The ...

Im fact, after part 12, my wife told me she was sorry that I was so disappointed by this new show, especially since I had been looking forward to it so much. I looked at her with confusion, and explained how much I liked it and how I thought it had lived up to my expectations. She responded, "...

Don't, I've really enjoyed your posts. That wasn't meant to be a 'Get out of this thread!' more like don't get too offended. I don't know. I started the thread but it's not my thread anymore than yours. I'm not trying to tell anyone what to do, just that really in a thread with this title, venting ...

Yeah this is the thing though, I'm sort of saying it's been mostly nice up until now but disappointment it turning into something worse, so all I ask is that you understand that is probably going to come through more and more. Some people who shall not be named get quite offended when we start crit...

We can't help liking the show any more than you can help hating it. But how can you like it when it literally corrupts the original material so completely? Do you like the season as a stand alone? Or do you like the fact it changes the meaning of the original so completely.? Does that then mean you...

Mtwentz, LateReg,Yaxomoxay (prob messed up the spelling, sorry) - you seem like good people. But please understand at this point I and several others are probably beyond disappointed and kind of angry about this. Can you please just allow us to vent about this? It's really beyond the discussion poi...

@boske: Do you have a problem if we find some issues in this "Return"? (as laid out, go and read it, a few pages back). Do we all have to like it? Do I go on the main thread and preach there? People come here and call us haters, fine, it was in good fun. No objections. No, of course i hav...

I think that was deliberate, like the woodsman at the convenience store. Electrical interference :D Thanks! I figured that was the case, but since no one had mentioned it I was starting to wonder. I definitely noticed it too and wondered the same as you did. Thank you for bringing it up. No problem...

Notice the finger in Sarah's head. sarafing.JPG And I can't put my finger on it (no pun intended), but this little snapshot reminds me of some famous recent contemporary artist's work. Anyone know? In this case, it is Lynch the painter. sarasmile.JPG Damn this is creepy. George Costanza had no idea...

Me too. The camera movement was similar as well. Speaking of camera movement, did anyone else notice the digital stutter when Hawk, Bobby, Andy, amnd Truman when they were approaching the vortex locale, or was that just my stream messing up? I think that was deliberate, like the woodsman at the con...

Anyone else notice how that enormous tree stump at Jack Rabbit's palace resembles that palace (?) atop the mountain in the purple/mauve zone or white lodge? Or am I being overly creative here... I noticed it as well. Me too. The camera movement was similar as well. Speaking of camera movement, did ...

N. Needleman wrote:Oh my God. What if Audrey is locked in that fucking basement.

I can't fathom what scenario you're dreaming up here, Needleman, but it sounds interesting. Why would you suspect she would be in there?

Ok fine, I'm not out to denigrate Lynch personally. [...] But I seriously question his bizarre choices. Can I at least say that? All I needed from page 1 (and I disagree about the music, or that he has contempt). And tbh I could give a fuck about this argument after what went down in Virginia today...

Maybe this thread isn't that much of an discussion thread, and more of a vetilation thread. I think it's good that people can come to this thread and vent their frustration with The Return, and even if it's speculation of Lynch's mental state. I mean, when some of us feel that Lynch/Frost has made ...