What exactly do you think TP fans did on this forum and many others for 25 fucking years? There is a very clear and distinct difference between speculation about things we've seen on the screen and just pulling things out of absolutely nowhere. This thread is mostly the latter, these theories stand...

I'm sorry, but this theorizing is a bit silly. You all realize that this is pretty much fan fiction, right? A couple things have just gone totally outside of anything that. This. What is seen on screen or later confirmed by Lynch or Frost count. The rest is just as relevant as a theory that the voi...

IcedOver wrote: Honestly, I can't believe such analysis has been done over five words, a throwaway comedic line.

Well, there's no plot or characters to analyze, so the attention is drawn to editing glitches and awkward jokes.

I've completely lost track of this thread now. So I'll just throw in my two cents randomly. One thing I liked about S3 was Gordon Cole, and Albert. If Cole hadn't been in the original, it would have felt really weird to shoehorn Lynch in front of the camera, but since he was, it would have been just...

Agreed 100%. Very simple fixes that still would have allowed S3 to have its own persona and keep the themes and styles that apparently make it art. It didn't need to be a shit story to be art, that was just the result of bad writing.

Back on topic:

I refuse to believe that anyone who is a fan of original Twin Peaks wasn't disappointed that out of 18 hours we got 15 minutes of Cooper being Cooper. There is no way that didn't let you down.

The conversation has been badly derailed by a single person going on a sexist rant, followed by by TP:TR defenders saying that's what all the criticism is. We're way too far from the lack of plot, paper thin characters, hours of wasted scenes, plot inconsistencies, lack of atmosphere, lack of resolu...

I honestly don't think that us supporters are ignoring the flaws or whitewashing the errors, as some have said. This is a work of art that seems to operate on the level of reality and dream and projection (and tulpa) as well as meta-concoction communicating with the audience and the artist himself ...

Doesn't matter, my point is that I find the argument that everyone is as qualified to evaluate the merits of an artwork to be not thought through. So what you're saying is that you are not qualified to evaluate the merits of TP:TR and therefore we should ignore you when you come to this thread prai...

eyeboogers wrote:Everyone has the right to express their informed opinion.

So, what are your credentials? Which university has given you the vast education needed to state an opinion on a TV-show?

Cappy wrote:Is it still commonly assumed that Billy is the drunk is the jail cell?

I'm still confused as to what difference does it make. The man in the cell doesn't interact with anyone who refers to Billy, so it doesn't matter.

Also, I seriously doubt that either Lynch or Frost has spared any significant thought on the matter. They use whatever feels and looks good for the scenes they need.

I suspected just based on the original series that Black Lodge and White Lodge are names Native Americans of the area gave to a phenomenon they observed in only small part. The spirits surely don't care how humans divide and name their world. S3 seems to go into this direction, by showing us several...

someone made a really compelling argument to convince me that I might change my opinion if viewing the series from a different perspective. This is why I still come here. I'm looking for someone to point out things about S3 that I find interesting enough. Character interactions, story, coherence, m...

mtwentz wrote:But then again, I shouldn't be surprised since FWWM provoked a similar reaction if I recall correctly.

I am curious about this. I remember feeling gutted and frustrated when I first saw FWWM, and I love it now. I wonder if I'll come around to S3. Can't see it happening now, but time will tell.