So what's the true deal with this "alternate universe" inconsistency stuff. They said it about FWWM, and they're saying it about the book too. What does that mean? Just that they're somehow mangling the timeline in the Lodges? I really think the inconsistencies in the book were unintentio...

Did you guys play Gone Home a few years back? You basically explore this big empty house in the middle of the woods at night during a thunderstorm, and your family is supposed to be there, but they're all missing. It was good. I think a Peaks game in a similar vein would really work: Atmospheric, ex...

- Hawk's tone in his portion read to me as kinda, well, douchey. And kinda anachronistic? I was alive in the '80s, but not old enough to remember if "nookie" was slang back then? I dunno, a minor thing, but something I noticed. I don't know if this helps, but I remember seeing an episode ...

I don't want to go into the social media history from actors- everyone is human and most of us have said things on social media that we probably wish we hadn't. And also sometimes things get blown out of proportion... This board is certainly no different. Agreed. I'd like to keep discussion regardi...

I finished the book last weekend and really enjoyed it. Mark is a great storyteller. Loved the historical tie-ins, which led to many-a-Wikipedia binge. May or may not be more of a UFO conspiracist now. Some questions (and apologies, I haven't read the entire thread yet): - Any ideas of what the &quo...

Hi all. Audrey Horne, just want to tell you how engrossing and special this thread is. You do an amazing job analysing the Audrey character. I'm in the middle of my re-watch for S3... currently on Billy Zane's character's intro episode (ugh). The breakdown of the Cooper/Audrey storyline is truly a s...

Cooper is confronted by Caroline's doppleganger as well as Maddy's, two women he failed. So maybe you could say it's tailor made. I don't think it has to do with BOB. That's a really interesting observation. Myself, I'd always assumed that Maddy's soul was trapped because of her strong connection t...

Hi all, new here. In the middle of reading the Secret History, so apologies if any of my queries are answered there. :) So, the finale's Black Lodge scene is one of my favourite in the entire series, but I have a lot of questions. First, I am confused as to who gets an appearance in the Black Lodge ...